The following article has appeared in the latest edition (Spring) of the
RSA Journal, the house magazine of the RSA.
Slow and Steady . . .
Robert Kelsey argues that, far from being restricted to the privileged few, entrepreneurial opportunities abound in all walks of life
The coalition government believes that private-sector employment can replace the jobs being lost in the public sector, with start-up businesses being hailed as crucial contributors in this respect. At a time of continued economic uncertainty, however, can we really expect people from all social groups to embrace enterprise? Indeed, couldn’t it be considered socially irresponsible to encourage economically vulnerable people to bet their meagre life savings on a venture?
Yet for those facing social exclusion, entrepreneurship is potentially a liberating career choice. Surveys of UK entrepreneurs, such as recent research by data analysts Experian, show that ethnic minorities (including the Irish) and those with learning difficulties such as dyslexia are over-represented. This suggests that entrepreneurship is a naturally effective equal-opportunities arena, perhaps even counterbalancing ingrained prejudice in more formal working environments.
“The wish to overcome prejudice is a key reason why many people start out on their own,” says RSA Fellowship Council member Emma Jones, head of small-business support initiative Enterprise Nation. “Running your own business is fantastically meritocratic. It is also flexible in ways that employment simply cannot be, hence the large number of young mums starting businesses.”
Exclusion concerns do, of course, exist among budding entrepreneurs but they go beyond ethnic, gender, age and ability divides. This is creating a new kind of social gap: between people with high fear of failure (whom I call ‘High-FFs’) and their opposites, those with high achievement motivation (‘High-AMs’).
Fear of failure is a condition from which millions suffer, irrespective of gender, class, ethnicity or age. High-FFs approach tasks expecting failure and dreading the potential for public humiliation that such failure brings. This leads them to employ avoidance techniques that, ultimately, confirm their negative predictions. While many would love to start a business – often because they feel overlooked or belittled in their current situation – they are afraid of the risks involved, making fear of failure both a debilitating and self-fulfilling affliction.
TV programmes such as BBC’s Dragons’ Den don’t help. This is behind-the-sofa viewing for most High-FF would-be entrepreneurs, whose resolve to start a business is likely to be eroded with every public roasting from a ‘Dragon’. The steely traits that form the public image of the Dragons are a long way from those of the typical High-FF.
Like the Dragons, successful entrepreneurs create their own mythology. For instance, in his book The Beermat Entrepreneur, start-up guru Mike Southon writes: “Entrepreneurs are confident. They are born optimists: they simply know they can do it. Entrepreneurs are also charismatic. They inspire people…they have optimism to spare. Entrepreneurs are also arrogant. They know they are good.”
Yet entrepreneurialism has nothing to do with hardwired personality traits. Like so many other celebrity entrepreneurs, Southon is describing himself, while conveying an image of entrepreneurship that is overly aggressive, short-sighted and unfair, not least because it alienates – and therefore excludes – so many potential entrepreneurs.
A recent survey, presented at the UK launch of Global Entrepreneurship Week, revealed that about 50% of the UK population are considering becoming their own boss, yet only 5% are doing something about it. So what’s stopping the other 45%? Partly fear of the risks and costs associated with starting a new business, and partly fear that they do not fit the stereotype of the ‘maverick’ entrepreneur.
Emma Jones points out that most budding entrepreneurs are simply looking for freedom and flexibility in their working life. The typical small-business owner, she says, is a “mum who starts a business to earn extra money for the household while still being able to do the school run”. She adds: “This is a long way from the defy-all-odds swashbuckling heroes who are most associated with entrepreneurship.”
So what can be done? Support mechanisms such as Enterprise Nation are a start, but what about funding? Fear of the financial consequences of failure is a key barrier, making the reintroduction of the Thatcher-era Enterprise Allowance Scheme for the unemployed a strong move.
Yet many people overestimate the financial requirements for a start-up enterprise. Jones says that the best way to start a business is modestly: through cautious planning and by sticking to a strict budget, perhaps while working from home or, at least at first, continuing with the day job.
This is a crucial message. In some ways, too much funding can actually disadvantage entrepreneurs in the early stages of their venture. Grants, for instance, can create unnecessary and potentially fear-inducing liabilities, such as forcing a start-up to operate at a higher level than its income comfortably allows, thereby saddling it with unaffordable costs once the grant has been spent.
An effective alternative is self-financing, and especially ‘bootstrapping’, which involves entrepreneurs – especially nervous ones – starting small and staying within their means. Fred DeLuca, founder of sandwich chain Subway, began with an investment of US$1,000 (£750) and bootstrapped his way to a fortune. He relied on cash flow to expand and never over-extended himself through debt or equity, both of which bring external obligations that can increase both the risk and the fear.
“Just because it is small doesn’t mean the business can’t grow,” writes DeLuca in his book Start Small, Finish Big. “And, while it is small, you will have the time to learn the lessons that are essential to your future success.”
Such sentiments certainly undermine any notions of inequality when it comes to succeeding as an entrepreneur: quite the opposite. Indeed, fearful people of modest means are just as well suited to entrepreneurship as their bolder, more affluent counterparts. They may even be more so, given the need for start-ups to be grounded and sustainable, rather than overnight sensations.
Entrepreneurship can be isolating, however, which can compound fears, erode resolve and increase the failure rate. At Metrocube (an early noughties incubator for dotcom start-ups where I was CEO), our aim was to get would-be entrepreneurs out of their bedrooms and into a community environment where they could swap ideas and favours with a network of like-minded individuals. Fostering camaraderie is also one of the goals at the heart of Enterprise Nation and other collegiate initiatives such as the Institute of Entrepreneurs, run by RSA chairman Luke Johnson.
Networks offer more than just advice and resources. While these are helpful, it is the shared concerns and sense of fellowship that are vital to the lonely entrepreneur, especially if his or her own socio-economic grouping is under-represented in entrepreneurial circles. Mentoring can also be valuable, although care is needed when trying to impose formal structures on individuals who may just be looking for shared experiences, occasional guidance and – most importantly – a network.
Networks, however, are only part of the answer. More importantly, the image of entrepreneurship needs to change so that it encourages both the cautious and the fearful, proving that this most meritocratic of economic sectors is open to all.
Robert Kelsey FRSA is a businessman and author
Robert Kelsey’s book, What’s Stopping You? Why Smart People Don’t Always Reach Their Potential, and How You Can will be published by Capstone/Wiley in April 2011
[pull quote] Entrepreneurialism has nothing to do with hardwired personality traits
[call to action] The RSA’s Social Entrepreneurs Network provides a source of support and advice to Fellows interested in social enterprise. Join in the discussion at www.RSAfellowship.com/group/socialentrepreneursnetwork
What's stops smart people from reaching their potential? Fear of failure. This blog supports Robert Kelsey's new book on overcoming fear of failure: What's Stopping You? (now on Amazon.co.uk).
Showing posts with label Dragon's Den. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dragon's Den. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
When it comes to enterprise, take it slow and steady
Labels:
bootstrapping,
Dragon's Den,
dyslexia,
Emma Jones,
enterprise nation,
Experian,
fear of failure,
Fred DeLuca,
Metrocube,
RSA
Thursday, December 9, 2010
It’s the faux morality of the media that irritates
As a journalist turned PR (via banking) I’m often asked whether I miss journalism. Sometimes is the answer, although I do plenty of writing, which was the bit I loved most. In fact I love the media and still enjoy my role in it. What I don’t miss, however, is the faux morality of journalism, which I was reminded of again this week following James Naughtie’s slip of the tongue on Radio 4’s Today programme. For those who missed it, Naughtie made the classic near-Spoonerist mistake of mixing up the letters of Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt’s name to produce the one Anglo-Saxon word that taste still precludes from everyday usage. Inexplicably, Andrew Marr then repeated the mistake on Start the Week.
This is pretty harmless stuff, although their apologies – through suppressed guffawing – was the bit that reminded me of the media’s faux morality. These were clearly not heartfelt apologies, which is fine for the media-savvy cognoscente – no offence was really meant by the gaffs. But my guess is that it was the apologies – not the inadvertent swearing – that would have compounded, rather than relieved, any offence caused to more sensitive ears.
I realise this sounds petty, especially from an Essex lad who would have used the gerund of the “f” word to introduce every noun as a schoolboy, but I’ve had some insight into the other side from knowing, and respecting, my mother-in-law. She is a woman of the 1950s. A Royalist, a churchgoer, an old school Tory who always had great faith in the BBC as the mouthpiece of the nation, until recently. And she wouldn’t have taken offence at Naughtie’s slip. In fact, I doubt she’d have even picked up on it so untuned is her ear to coarse language. Yet the unmeant “apologies” delivered through stifled mirth would have, indeed, offended her. That’s what I mean by the faux morality of the media.
In fact, my only compliant to the BBC was on behalf of my mother-in-law. The 10pm news was immediately preceded by a trailer that was nothing more than a stream of shouted swear words from an actor – beginning and ending with “f**king”. She was obviously shocked and, seeing it from her point of view, I sent an email complaint – pointing out that many people tune in specifically to the 10pm News and your 9.59 and 50 seconds timing for the shouted expletives was pretty inconsiderate if not deliberately provocative. I received one of those “sorry you were offended” non-apologies followed by some nonsense reeking of faux morality. “We take our obligations very seriously with respect to warning viewers of potentially offensive material,” it bleated (or something like it) before excusing themselves with such smug arrogance they may as well have sent a picture of the respondent giving me the finger. It would have certainly been more fitting.
As an ex-journalist, I carry my own guilt in this respect – in fact mine is worse because I caused someone to lose their job. When editor of a business magazine I carried a story regarding the behaviour of a bank that had recently changed direction thanks to the appointment of a new director, brought in from the US. I had no idea regarding the figures, or whether this was a good idea in the long-term. I was going on industry gossip, from rivals. Nonetheless, the tone of the article can be easily surmised by the fact we shamefully accompanied the article with a full-page cover cartoon of the bank – clearly represented in human form – shooting itself in the foot. The director, at the time one of few women directors of a European bank, did not survive the poor publicity.
In fact her departure – which may have been for a host of reasons, not just the article – shocked me into re-evaluating my role as a financial journalist. I admired the sector I reported on and began to feel that I’d betrayed it – with the feeling growing with every congratulatory note or phone call I received from other journos (this was pre-email). Yet when confronted by the bank’s PR, I defended the article on the grounds of “public interest” of course. “Stakeholders in the bank have a right to know” blah – but both he and I knew it was tosh. I’d repeated, exaggerated and luridly expressed industry gossip, and no amount of faux morality was going to cover that up.
What has all this got to do with What’s Stopping You? my book on overcoming fear of failure? Quite a lot, actually, because it’s the media’s treatment of vulnerable people that is most at play when it comes to its faux morality. We may immediately think of Susan Boyle – a woman with very apparent vulnerability who shot to fame because of her extraordinary singing voice – yet she’s fine: her fame should compensate her adequately for her Faustian pact with the media.
My main concern, however, are the 1,000s of failed Susan Boyles who are sucked into the media machine – usually via reality TV – and then destroyed by it. Thinking fame their destiny, they are thrust into the limelight and encouraged to behave outrageously, before being thrown off after some humiliating vote or judgement from a panel of celebs (Big Brother, X-Factor, The Apprentice, Dragon’s Den – are all versions of this).
Of course, as we giggle at the humiliation we are comforted by the notion that they volunteer for this modern-day version of gladiatorial combat. Yet in many cases their dreams of celebrity were the classic avoidance tactics of High-FFs (as I call those with a high fear of failure in my book, and as explained in previous posts). Riddled with insecurities, they assume celebrity will cure them, which makes them willing fodder for a media machine that has found reality TV a cheap and popular genre in an age of proliferating channels and tightening budgets. And, of course, the odd casualty can be dealt with by serious statements of concern, funeral attendance (if it gets that far) and other tactics from the Media Book of Faux Morality.
But not all the victims are “volunteers”, or so easily dealt with. Probably the most shocking example I can remember happened on a local radio station. The expansion of local radio in the UK in the 1980s led to some pretty desperate programming to acquire an audience, one of which was the agony aunt phone-in. Seared into my memory is the call from a recently-widowed woman pouring her heart out over the loss of her husband. “I miss him,” she kept saying, “I just miss him so much, I can’t live without him.” This went on for no more than two minutes (maybe less) before it became clear that, having enjoyed her on-air blubbing at first, she was unlikely to add anything more juicy to the programme.
In fact, her refusal to cheer up was becoming a bit boring, so they cut her off and went to another caller. Concerned this appeared brutal, they later spoke of their deep concern for the woman, and that she’d been passed on to a non-existent back-up team of professional counsellors able to deal with her very specific grief-based agonies. Meanwhile, John in Basildon’s got an erectile disfunction problem he wants to share with the entire county. Faux morality indeed.
This is pretty harmless stuff, although their apologies – through suppressed guffawing – was the bit that reminded me of the media’s faux morality. These were clearly not heartfelt apologies, which is fine for the media-savvy cognoscente – no offence was really meant by the gaffs. But my guess is that it was the apologies – not the inadvertent swearing – that would have compounded, rather than relieved, any offence caused to more sensitive ears.
I realise this sounds petty, especially from an Essex lad who would have used the gerund of the “f” word to introduce every noun as a schoolboy, but I’ve had some insight into the other side from knowing, and respecting, my mother-in-law. She is a woman of the 1950s. A Royalist, a churchgoer, an old school Tory who always had great faith in the BBC as the mouthpiece of the nation, until recently. And she wouldn’t have taken offence at Naughtie’s slip. In fact, I doubt she’d have even picked up on it so untuned is her ear to coarse language. Yet the unmeant “apologies” delivered through stifled mirth would have, indeed, offended her. That’s what I mean by the faux morality of the media.
In fact, my only compliant to the BBC was on behalf of my mother-in-law. The 10pm news was immediately preceded by a trailer that was nothing more than a stream of shouted swear words from an actor – beginning and ending with “f**king”. She was obviously shocked and, seeing it from her point of view, I sent an email complaint – pointing out that many people tune in specifically to the 10pm News and your 9.59 and 50 seconds timing for the shouted expletives was pretty inconsiderate if not deliberately provocative. I received one of those “sorry you were offended” non-apologies followed by some nonsense reeking of faux morality. “We take our obligations very seriously with respect to warning viewers of potentially offensive material,” it bleated (or something like it) before excusing themselves with such smug arrogance they may as well have sent a picture of the respondent giving me the finger. It would have certainly been more fitting.
As an ex-journalist, I carry my own guilt in this respect – in fact mine is worse because I caused someone to lose their job. When editor of a business magazine I carried a story regarding the behaviour of a bank that had recently changed direction thanks to the appointment of a new director, brought in from the US. I had no idea regarding the figures, or whether this was a good idea in the long-term. I was going on industry gossip, from rivals. Nonetheless, the tone of the article can be easily surmised by the fact we shamefully accompanied the article with a full-page cover cartoon of the bank – clearly represented in human form – shooting itself in the foot. The director, at the time one of few women directors of a European bank, did not survive the poor publicity.
In fact her departure – which may have been for a host of reasons, not just the article – shocked me into re-evaluating my role as a financial journalist. I admired the sector I reported on and began to feel that I’d betrayed it – with the feeling growing with every congratulatory note or phone call I received from other journos (this was pre-email). Yet when confronted by the bank’s PR, I defended the article on the grounds of “public interest” of course. “Stakeholders in the bank have a right to know” blah – but both he and I knew it was tosh. I’d repeated, exaggerated and luridly expressed industry gossip, and no amount of faux morality was going to cover that up.
What has all this got to do with What’s Stopping You? my book on overcoming fear of failure? Quite a lot, actually, because it’s the media’s treatment of vulnerable people that is most at play when it comes to its faux morality. We may immediately think of Susan Boyle – a woman with very apparent vulnerability who shot to fame because of her extraordinary singing voice – yet she’s fine: her fame should compensate her adequately for her Faustian pact with the media.
My main concern, however, are the 1,000s of failed Susan Boyles who are sucked into the media machine – usually via reality TV – and then destroyed by it. Thinking fame their destiny, they are thrust into the limelight and encouraged to behave outrageously, before being thrown off after some humiliating vote or judgement from a panel of celebs (Big Brother, X-Factor, The Apprentice, Dragon’s Den – are all versions of this).
Of course, as we giggle at the humiliation we are comforted by the notion that they volunteer for this modern-day version of gladiatorial combat. Yet in many cases their dreams of celebrity were the classic avoidance tactics of High-FFs (as I call those with a high fear of failure in my book, and as explained in previous posts). Riddled with insecurities, they assume celebrity will cure them, which makes them willing fodder for a media machine that has found reality TV a cheap and popular genre in an age of proliferating channels and tightening budgets. And, of course, the odd casualty can be dealt with by serious statements of concern, funeral attendance (if it gets that far) and other tactics from the Media Book of Faux Morality.
But not all the victims are “volunteers”, or so easily dealt with. Probably the most shocking example I can remember happened on a local radio station. The expansion of local radio in the UK in the 1980s led to some pretty desperate programming to acquire an audience, one of which was the agony aunt phone-in. Seared into my memory is the call from a recently-widowed woman pouring her heart out over the loss of her husband. “I miss him,” she kept saying, “I just miss him so much, I can’t live without him.” This went on for no more than two minutes (maybe less) before it became clear that, having enjoyed her on-air blubbing at first, she was unlikely to add anything more juicy to the programme.
In fact, her refusal to cheer up was becoming a bit boring, so they cut her off and went to another caller. Concerned this appeared brutal, they later spoke of their deep concern for the woman, and that she’d been passed on to a non-existent back-up team of professional counsellors able to deal with her very specific grief-based agonies. Meanwhile, John in Basildon’s got an erectile disfunction problem he wants to share with the entire county. Faux morality indeed.
Labels:
Andrew Marr,
Dragon's Den,
James Naughtie,
Jeremy Hunt,
Radio 4,
Start the Week,
The Apprentice,
Today,
X-Factor
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)